Select Page

Pols & Theories return with Special Guest The GODFAVRE. We preview, debate, and discuss Christmas weekend, give our Week 16 picks, and talk about which QB’s we’d want for the next 5 years over Justin Herbert. 

A. Jaguars at Jets (Pick)

  • Do the Jags take care of business?
  • Have they risen out of mediocrity with Trevor/Doug?
  • Is this a must win for Zach Wilson? (Jags, Seahawks, Dolphins last 3, do they lose out?)

B. Eagles at Cowboys (Dallas -5)

  • If Minshew starts and wins, what does this mean for the Eagles AND Cowboys?
  • 2004 McNabb, 2017 Wentz, 2022 Hurts – Who do you prefer?

C. Packers at Dolphins (Dolphins -4)

  • Can the Packers pull off the upset?
  • Packers 5% to make playoffs, do you see a path?
  • If Pack lose, Jordan Love?
  • What happens if the Dolphins lose?

D. Texans at Titans (Titans -5)

  • Must win for Titans?(Texans, Cowboys, Jags)
  • Will the division come down to the last game?
  • What happened to this team?
  • Is this Tannehill’s last season as the starter?

E. Would you rather for the next 5 years (Justin Herbert edition)

  • Dak Prescott
  • Jalen Hurts
  • Joe Burrow
  • Josh Allen
  • Trevor Lawrence
  • Aaron Rodgers
  • Tom Brady
  • Tua Tagovailoa
  • Russell Wilson
  • DeShaun Watson

F. Christmas Eve

  • Falcons at Ravens (Falcons -7.5)
  • Bills at Bears (Bills -9)
  • Saints at Browns (Browns-2.5)
  • Seahawks at Chiefs (Chiefs -9.5)
  • Giants at Vikings (Vikings-4)
  • Bengals at Patriots (Bengals -3)
  • Commanders at 49ers (49ers -7)
  • Raiders at Steelers (Steelers -2.5)

Christmas Day

  • Packers at Dolphins (Dolphins -4)
  • Broncos at Rams (Broncos -2.5)
  • Buccaneers at Cardinals (Buccaneers -6.5)


  • Chargers at Colts (Chargers -4)

Psychotic & Iconic Sports Podcast is powered by The Props Network at for all of their latest show news, new episodes, and livestreams!

Psychotic & Iconic is brought to you by PrizePicks, your home for daily fantasy sports. New players who sign up on PrizePicks today using the promo code ICONIC will receive a 100% instant deposit match up to $100. PrizePicks: Daily Fantasy Made Easy!

Follow P&I on their video and audio platforms: YouTube, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeart, Google Podcasts, Stitcher, Megaphone!

Also follow The P&I Guys on their social media platforms: Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and TikTok!

View the links to all of their above platforms on Linktree and Shorby!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit